Market Dynamics & Pricing
Understanding the forces that drive carbon prices up and down
Your Progress
Section 4 of 5What Drives Carbon Prices?
Carbon markets are notoriously volatile. Prices can swing wildly based on three primary forces:
📦
Supply Factors
- •Credit issuance volumes
- •Project pipeline growth
- •Allowance allocation (compliance)
- •Banking and borrowing rules
- •Standard changes (ICR, Verra reforms)
🛒
Demand Factors
- •Corporate net-zero commitments
- •Regulatory compliance requirements
- •Voluntary buyer appetite
- •Quality skepticism vs. urgency
- •Speculative trading activity
⚖️
Policy Signals
- •National climate ambition (NDCs)
- •Carbon taxes and pricing policies
- •International agreements (COP outcomes)
- •Subsidy and incentive programs
- •Border carbon adjustments (CBAM)
📊 Carbon Price Dynamics Engine
Market Price per tCO₂
$40
→ 0.0%($0 from baseline)
Neutral
Shortage ←→ Oversupply
Neutral
Weak Demand ←→ Strong Demand
Neutral
Weak Policy ←→ Strong Policy
💡 What's Happening:
Baseline equilibrium—no shocks applied
Historical Price Shocks:
Market Segmentation & Price Divergence
Not all carbon credits trade at the same price. Quality, permanence, and co-benefits create distinct market tiers:
💎
Premium Tier
$100-600/tCO₂
Examples:
Direct Air Capture • Biochar with geological storage • Enhanced weathering
Characteristics:
- •High permanence
- •Gold-standard MRV
- •Tech-based removals
- •Limited supply
🌲
Mid-Market
$20-80/tCO₂
Examples:
High-quality reforestation • Mangrove restoration • Soil carbon (verified)
Characteristics:
- •Nature-based removals
- •Co-benefits
- •Moderate permanence
- •Growing supply
⚡
Commodity
$3-15/tCO₂
Examples:
Renewable energy (mature markets) • Energy efficiency • Fuel switching
Characteristics:
- •Avoided emissions
- •Additionality concerns
- •Abundant supply
- •Lower integrity risk
⚠️
Distressed
$0.50-5/tCO₂
Examples:
REDD+ (low-quality) • Cookstoves (weak MRV) • Oversupplied renewables
Characteristics:
- •Quality doubts
- •Integrity scandals
- •Weak verification
- •Buyer avoidance
🔮 Future Price Trajectories
Bull Case (High Prices):
- • Rapid expansion of compliance markets (CBAM, CORSIA)
- • Quality crackdown reduces supply, tightens standards
- • Corporate accountability drives demand for premium removals
- • Result: $50-150/tCO₂ for high-quality credits by 2030
Bear Case (Low Prices):
- • Integrity scandals erode buyer trust, demand collapses
- • Oversupply from nature-based projects floods market
- • Weak climate policy and recession dampen appetite
- • Result: $5-20/tCO₂ stagnation for low-quality credits